The Little Cockerel and the Hedge. A fresh take on OCD.

There was once a cockerel who went scratching in the hedge and scratched so hard the hedge collapsed. When the magpie came along and asked what happened the hedge said, ‘the cockerel came and scratched me so much I collapsed.’ Well then,’ said the Magpie, ‘I will pull out my tail feathers.’ Then the Magpie went and sat in the walnut tree which asked him why he seemed so scruffy. ‘The cockerel scratched the hedge so much it collapsed, so I pulled out my tail feathers.’ Well,’ said the walnut tree, ‘then I will clip off all my branches.’

When the deer came by the walnut tree she asked what had happened; ‘The cockerel scratched the hedge so much it collapsed, the magpie pulled out his tail feathers and then I clipped off all my branches.’ ‘Oh, said the deer, ‘then I will chase my sons away.’ The deer then went to the well. It asked her where her sons were and so the deer explained, ‘the cockerel scratched the hedge so much it collapsed, the magpie pulled out his tail feathers, the walnut tree clipped off all its branches and so then I chased my sons away.’ ‘I see’ said the well, ‘then I will turn my water to blood.’

When Sarah the maid came along to collect water she asked, ‘why is your water all turned to blood?’ ‘The cockerel scratched the hedge so much it collapsed, the magpie pulled out his tail feathers and then the walnut tree clipped off all its branches, then the deer chased her sons away and then I turned my water to blood.’ ‘ So,’ said Sarah, ‘then I will beat myself with the pail,’ and she bludgeoned herself till the pail broke in two.

When she got back, the mistress asked why she was so bruised. ‘The cockerel scratched the hedge so much it collapsed, then the magpie pulled out his tail feathers, the walnut tree clipped off all its branches, the deer chased her sons away, the well turned its water to blood and so I beat myself with the pail.’ ‘Ah,’ said the mistress, ‘then I will smear all my dough on the wall’. When her husband got home he asked about the smeared dough and the wife explained, ‘The cockerel scratched the hedge so much it collapsed, the magpie pulled out his tail feathers, the walnut tree clipped off all its branches, then the deer chased her sons away, the well turned its water to blood, Sarah beat herself with the pail and so I then smeared my dough on the wall.’ ‘I see,’ said the husband, ‘then I will shave off my beard.’

When their son got home and wondered what on earth had happened his father exclaimed, ‘such trouble we’ve had today, the cockerel scratched the hedge so much it collapsed, so the magpie pulled out his tail feathers, then the walnut tree clipped off all its branches, the deer chased her sons away, the well turned its water to blood, Sarah beat herself with the pail, mother then smeared her dough on the wall and I shaved off my beard.’ Goodness me’ said the son, ‘then I will chop off the legs of my oxen,’ and he took an axe and chopped of the leg of one of his oxen.

In that moment a soldier came by and yelled, ‘for God’s sake, what are you doing?’ The boy patiently explained, ‘well you see, the cockerel scratched the hedge so much it collapsed, the magpie pulled out his tail feathers, then the walnut tree clipped off all its branches, the deer chased her sons away, the well turned its water to blood, Sarah beat herself with the pail, mother then smeared her dough on the wall, so father shaved off his beard and I chopped off the legs of my oxen.’ “What a damn fool you are!’ yelled the soldier, ‘how has that helped anything?’ and he whacked the boy with the flat of his sword, took the oxen to market, sold them and got married on the proceeds.

One of the most pernicious and toxic things we can do to ourselves is to hold the conviction that there is any such thing as a ‘negative emotion.’ It’s not simply intolerant prejudice dressed up as virtue, though that is bad enough. Nor does the rot stop at gaslighting your experience by making it bad and wrong for daring to have a feeling. Nor is it limited to the destructive effect upon relatedness created by claiming the moral high ground and refusing to engage with life when it fails to meet unrealistic and potentially persecutory ideals.

Neither is this particular brand of philosophical fascism limited to the erosion of relationships via the self-righteous sanctimony of somehow being above entering the less-than-perfect world of others. Its worst effect is upon the interior landscape of the person who holds such convictions, firstly because it sets a person against everything inside them which fails to live up to ‘positive’ ideals and secondly because such a propping up of the persona means individuation, with its necessary conflicts and paradoxes, grinds to a halt.

But the worst and most dangerous aspect of taking such a pejorative view of difficult emotions is suggested in our story; it leads to a form of obsessive, self destructive contagion in place of the empathy which can bear the discomfort of raw feelings. Since the magpie cannot allow himself to identify with the tragedy which has befallen the hedge he is compelled to pull out his tail feathers in unconscious identity instead. This psychic contagion then spreads to the walnut tree who, likewise, cannot abide the prospect of feeling into the plight of the magpie and has to act out his feelings instead by clipping off his branches and so on. Each party denies the legitimate suffering of the other, then their own. Sarah beats herself in place of empathic anguish for the well, the mistress destroys her dough rather than be moved by Sarah’s bruises, the husband is compelled to attack his beard and the son his oxen rather than face the fact that his parents have gone mad.

The psychic contagion is finally contained by the soldier who presumably has the inner resilience born of accustomization with conflict not to have to turn aside from lifer’s suffering and so can escape having to perpetuate it. Like Wordsworth’s Wanderer….

He had no painful pressure from without
That made him turn aside from wretchedness
With coward fears. He could ‘afford’ to suffer
With those whom he saw suffer. Hence it came
That in our best experience he was rich,
And in the wisdom of our daily life.

What’s notably absent in our story, leading from one calamity to another, is any distress or emotional concern for any of the disastrous events which unfold. The hedge doesn’t say, ‘this terrible thing happened to me’. We don’t have the magpie saying, ‘the awful impulse to rip out my tail feathers suddenly came over me.’ Sarah is not in tears over her broken head or the bloody well. The mistress is not perplexed at her dough now plastering the wall, nor is the husband bemused at feeling like a plucked chicken. For the want of ‘negative feelings’ the protagonists go mad. ‘Neurosis’, says Jung,’ is a substitute for legitimate suffering.’ Rather than allowing the complexity of emotional upset the characters develop self-destructive complexes instead. Whilst the repetition may be an attempt to master something that has not been psychologically assimilated, it becomes a means of avoiding the very experience that would make assimilation possible. What cannot be remembered or represented is then condemned to be enacted.

There is something terrifying about our story. It seems to represent what happens when ‘feeling with’, philosopher Schopenhauer’s concept of ‘mitleid’, or compassion, is missing in relationships. It suggests that there are consequences to this loss. It is not simply a choice to feel connected to others or not. When compassion is absent there is more than simple lack at stake. For the want of a feeling response to the plight of others we are compelled into an unconscious identification with them instead, invariably to our own detriment. ‘Feeling with’ is not optional. It is the natural expression of human instinctive being which, like sexuality, becomes distorted if not given adequate expression, turning against a person if diminished, condescended or suppressed. It should come as no surprise that Elon Musk’s recent assertion, ‘the fundamental weakness of Western civilisation is empathy’, should culminate in him destructively sinking 500 million dollars into a mid-term venture doomed to failure. His disparagement of ‘feeling with’ the collective needs of the people compelled him to pluck out his tail feathers instead.

Jung takes Schopenhauer a step further. ‘Feeling with’ is not simply matter of psychological hygiene. It is the principle source of consciousness and the engine driving the process of individuation. ‘Emotion is the alchemical fire whose warmth brings everything into existence and whose heat burns all superfluities to ashes. Emotion is the moment when steel meets flint and a spark is struck forth, for emotion is the chief source of consciousness. There is no change from darkness to light or from inertia to movement without emotion.” (CW9 para 179) This is echoed later by Iain McGilchrist, in his ‘The Master and His Emissary’, ’emotion is the basis for our engagement with the world.’

It is not enough to have intellectual insights. They have to be embodied as experience via feeling in order to inform the values which determine how we are to live. Jung makes the connection between ‘feeling with’ and values absolutely explicit, to the point where he makes them synonymous as ‘feeling/values..’, ‘which impose binding standards os ethical behaviour from which aestheticism and intellectualism are only too ready to emancipate themselves’. (CW16 p118)

The impact upon our values of this loss of ‘feeling with’ is expressed philosophically by Kierkegaard as ‘the despair of wanting to be oneself’, the defiant attempt to establish oneself through one’s own will, refusing relatedness or dependence, the desperate assertion of autonomy which then becomes a prison within the very construct so determined to secure itself. This barren and destructive isolation is amply symbolised by psychoanalyst Alan Wheelis in ‘On not knowing how to live,’ as ‘the moated castle’, an inability to inhabit feeling sufficiently to experience belonging, intimacy and participation in life, where introspection becomes encapsulated self-absorption, ‘I, who for so long have burrowed within, ever more deeply down and inward, live now in an airless world of phantoms.’ 

The need for belonging and connection will have its expression. It can be experienced directly as the troubled, respectful involvement with the subjective reality of the other, the difficult and sometimes painful walking-a-mile in the other’s shoes, or it can be experienced symptomatically as the obsessive compulsive tugging out of tail feathers, turning one’s life giving waters to blood, beating yourself with a pail or cutting the legs off your oxen.

Very often we tend to think of compulsive behaviour as something which gets in the way of relationships. Its a natural response to think about a partner’s obsessive cleaning as having the unfortunate consequence of frustrating intimacy, of one’s own need to polish the pelmets on a Saturday night as messing with your social life, of having to perform a ritual of obeisance to the Egyptian god Bastet every time someone uses the phrase ‘polymorphous perversity’ as a curse upon social acceptance, and yet you have to wonder if that is not the whole point. Perhaps we have the cart before the horse. Maybe obsessive ritual and compulsive action are not so much afflictions preventing relatedness but the price we have to pay precisely for avoiding connection, for refusing intimacy, for walling ourselves off in the moated castle. Our story suggests compulsion is a substitute for ‘feeling with’, and its enactment an attempt to manage experience which cannot be adequately encountered, felt or symbolically related to. What cannot be related to psychologically is acted out behaviourally.

It seems the task is to restore a capacity for relationship with what has been excluded that then makes entering the world of the other so difficult. If obsessionality is a defence against the vulnerability involved in depending upon another person or being depended upon by them, a failure to engage with an excluded aspect of oneself with a subsequent difficulty in relating to the other, then we need to be asking what it is about the empathic response that feels so threatening. If we imagine the story as a sequence of biographic events, the clue would seem to be right at the start, in early life, where the cockerel scratches the hedge to pieces and collapses it, where the active principle in the environment is destructive, intrusive and undermining to the child who can do very little to help itself and can only deal with all this self interested behaviour by ‘flattening’ its own response to being flattened. The turning point often comes, not by virtue of magically being able to suddenly feel something that was not there before, but through the realisation that a great loss has been suffered, for the loss to be mourned and a longing for that which has been lost to be returned its dignity.

And yes, it does feel significant that this whole trouble begins with a selfish cockerel, rather than a hen. In Carlos Byington’s ‘The Symbolic Perspective of the Obsessive-Compulsive Spectrum’, he suggests OCD involves a weakening of the containing, organising and delimiting functions associated with the adverse effects of the patriarchal archetype. In other words OCD is the result of an attack upon functions traditionally associated with the matriarchy. Ritualisation and repetitive behaviour then become attempts to compensate for this deficiency. Byington goes on to emphasise the importance of the therapeutic relationship in resolving issues related to OCD. In other words, healing is to be found in re-affirming the importance and value of relatedness, both interpersonally, with others, and intrapsychically, in so far as we may then have internal dialogues and restore the capacity for self-reflection.

Published by

andywhite

Psychotherapist/writer/artist/ author of, 'Going Mad to Stay Sane', a psychology of self-destructiveness, about to come into its third edition. Soon to be printed for the first time, 'Abundant Delicious.. the Secret and the Mystery', described by activist Satish Kumar as, ' A Tao of the Soul'. This book documents the archetypal country through which the process of individuation occurs and looks at the trials and tribulations we might expect on the way. In the meantime..... Narcissisim is the issue of our age. This blog looks at how it operates, how it can damage and how we may still fruit despite it.

Leave a Reply