The Queen Bee and Neurodiversity.

Two king’s sons went out into the world and fell into a wild disorderly way of living such that they never came home again. The third and youngest, whom they called ‘Dummling’, then set out to find them, though, when he eventually did so, they mocked him for imagining he could help them manage the world where they had failed, given they were so much more clever than he. All three then travelled together until they came to a large anthill. The older brothers thought to experiment with the anthill, to tear it down and watch the ants scurry about in a panic but the youngest stepped in, ‘Do not disturb them! Leave the creatures in peace!’ They further journeyed on until they came to a pond with some ducks swimming. The older brothers wanted to catch and roast them but Dummling would not allow it, ‘Do not disturb them! Leave the creatures in peace!’ Further still they came across a nest of bees. The older brothers wanted to smoke out the bees and take their honey but Dummling prevented them, ‘Do not disturb them! Leave the creatures in peace!’

Eventually the three brothers came to a great stone castle. Inside was a very old man who gave them bed and board. Next morning he summoned the eldest and gave him three tasks, the completion of which would free the castle from enchantment. The first task was to gather up the Princess’s pearls which had been scattered in the forest by sunset. If he missed even one he would be turned to stone. The boy searched methodically from tree to tree but by the end of the day had only a few and was turned to stone. The next day the second brother tried, he made grids and drew maps but faired no better and was also turned to stone. Then it was Dummling’s turn. He knew he must fail and sat on a stone weeping.

Just then, the king of the ants, whose home he had saved, turned up with his entire army and found every pearl by teatime. The second task was to find the key to the Princess’s bedchamber hidden at the bottom of the lake. Dummling knew he could not achieve such a task but lo and behold, the ducks he had saved from being roasted arrived and quickly found it. The third task was the most difficult, to identify the Princess, the king’s youngest daughter who looked so like her sisters they could not be told apart, except that each had had a different sweetmeat before the test, the first a bit of sugar, the second some syrup and the third some honey. Dummling knew he could not tell them apart but then the Queen of the Bees arrived and settled on the lips of the youngest Princess who’d eaten the honey and so the tasks were completed, the brothers restored and the enchantment lifted.

Dummling’s apparent deficiency is revealed as actually having a different relationship with the world than his ‘clever’ brothers. He is receptive to what others overlook. His attention is drawn towards small, apparently insignificant things, and he responds to them with an instinctive generosity. His attention is associative and distributed across the environment rather than subordinated to a predetermined objective. He is receptive to the unexpected; what appears irrelevant to the other brothers becomes essential to the eventual solution. His relationships are reciprocal rather than transactional. His apparent distractions and diversions establish relationships which subsequently prove indispensable.

This story gives us the possibility of considering psychic states which seem to be purely debilitating but which in fact are just what is required to face the challenges set by the Self, ‘the old man’. We could think of the Dummling in an intrapsychic way, ie, as a representation of the inferior function, the less developed aspects of the personality, but so too could we think of him as being an undervalued aspect of the collective psyche, a way of thinking and operating largely rejected and demeaned by our dominant culture.

Whilst acknowledging the very real problems faced by what we could broadly call neurodiversity, the story of the Queen Bee invites us to reconsider prejudices we may, with the best will in the world, still bring to bear and to think about the redemptive qualities as well as the limitations present in cognitive styles outside the mainstream. Putting the question of genetic predisposition and the influence of early experiences, which of course can exacerbate matters, to one side for a moment, lets think of the story as a compensatory corrective to preconceptions we collectively tend to have about modes of being which do not chime with cultural norms but that nevertheless can achieve and create where the ‘better adjusted’ fail.

In his work, ‘Symbols of Transformation’, Jung distinguishes two very different ways of thinking. The first, ‘directed thinking’, is verbal, logical and effortful. It is the means by which we plan, communicate, solve problems and organise our relationship with the external world. It is the style of thinking represented by the two older brothers. The second, ‘fantasy thinking’, is the style represented by the youngest; it is associative, imagistic, spontaneous and relatively independent of conscious direction. It is characteristic of dreaming, myth, fantasy and the imaginative activity of the unconscious. Rather than proceeding towards a predetermined goal, it follows its own psychic associations, drawing together apparently unrelated material and allowing new symbolic possibilities to emerge.

Given how different these two modes of thinking are, difficulties might understandably arise if they cannot establish a fruitful relationship with one another. What might otherwise burgeon as creative imagination can become distraction, fragmentation or an inability to translate inner possibilities into lived reality.

Dummling’s apparently inferior mode of functioning is actually closer to the working of the unconscious. What directed thinking often dismisses as irrelevant actually contains precisely what is required for psychological renewal. The redemptive possibility in our story is not the elimination of Dummling’s difference, but the discovery of its value. Characteristics regarded as deficient within one psychological economy become valuable within another.

What if some of what we are tempted to call neurotic inattention is, in part, the failure of directed consciousness to establish a sufficiently creative relationship with fantasy thinking? How would it be if we explored neurodiversity as the expression of a psyche whose associative, imaginative and exploratory capacities are insufficiently accommodated by the directing function of consciousness? If you try to pour a gallon into a pint pot there will be some messy spillage.

Our modern culture tends very much to favour directed thinking over fantasy thinking. The prejudice is that the dreamer staring out of the window or absorbed in his or her own world is doing something unproductive and even infantile.

‘This opinion, however, is not altogether satisfying. It is no doubt true that fantasy-thinking is not immediately productive, i.e., is unadapted and therefore useless for all practical purposes. But in the long run the play of fantasy uncovers creative forces and contents, just as dreams do. They are not in themselves infantile, much less pathological.‘ (para 38 CW5)

In the realm of science, which you would think is entirely circumscribed by directed thinking there are a number of notable exceptions which depended on the receptive and associative capacity of fantasy thinking. August Kekulé imagined a snake seizing its own tail, leading him to the ring structure of benzene. Dmitri Mendeleev dreamed of the periodic arrangement of the elements, which helped him formulate the periodic table. Niels Bohr used the planetary image of electrons orbiting a nucleus to develop his early atomic model. Albert Einstein imagined riding alongside a beam of light, a thought experiment that helped lead to special relativity. James Maxwell imagined invisible mechanical vortices and idler wheels to develop an intuitive model of electromagnetic fields. Otto Loewi dreamed of an experiment involving two frog hearts, leading to the discovery of chemical neurotransmission. Francis Crick drew on the image of a spiral staircase in thinking about DNA’s structure. Alexander Fleming recognised the significance of an apparently accidental mould contamination, allowing an unexpected observation to become the discovery of penicillin. Scientific discovery often requires a temporary suspension of directed, goal-oriented thinking, allowing an image, analogy, dream or unexpected association to emerge before rational thought can test and develop it. Author Robert Pirsig goes further, asserting that it is often when directive thinking grinds to a halt and we become utterly stuck that creative solutions then present themselves.

What is this life if, full of care,
We have no time to stand and stare.

No time to turn at Beauty’s glance,
And watch her feet, how they can dance.
(W.H. Davies 1911)

We undervalue receptivity, the capacity to pause, attend without purpose, and allow the world to make an impression upon us, rather than continually directing our attention towards an object. A child who is imaginative, associative, physically exploratory and resistant to sustained, externally imposed attention may be poorly matched to an educational environment which demands precisely the opposite.

This Sea that bares her bosom to the moon;
The winds that will be howling at all hours,
And are up-gathered now like sleeping flowers;
For this, for everything, we are out of tune;

It moves us not. Great God! I’d rather be
A Pagan suckled in a creed outworn;
So might I, standing on this pleasant lea,
Have glimpses that would make me less forlorn;

Have sight of Proteus rising from the sea;
Or hear old Triton blow his wreathèd horn
. (Wordsworth 1807)

The philosopher Martin Heidegger adds nuance to our theme by distinguishing two very different ways of being-in-the-world which seem to underpin and provide context for Jung’s two types of thinking. Heidegger describes two fundamentally different attitudes or ways of relating which he calls, ‘present-to-hand’ and ‘ready-at-hand’. The first mode of being, ‘present-at-hand’ describes our two clever brothers, who are not only task oriented and focused in their thinking but who are self-serving in their attitudes. They position themselves in the world through conscious calculation, judgement and instrumental use, treating its inhabitants and resources as objects to be exploited. The Dummling by contrast embodies an attitude which is ‘ready-to-hand’; he participates in the world rather than standing apart from it. His relationship with the ants, ducks and bees is one of practical responsiveness, respect and reciprocity. He doesn’t calculate their future usefulness; he enters into an intersubjective relationship with them. Dummling’s apparent foolishness represents a more immediate, relational intelligence, less dominated by the exploitative attitude of his brothers whose world is characterised by objectification and evaluated in terms of material resources. 

Dummling’s openness to the world enables a form of experience unavailable to the older brothers, more oriented to issues of meaning and purpose which then elicit a co-operative response from the world, kindness giving rise to good fortune.

This theme is one repeated time and again in fairytales from around the world. In ‘The Three Feathers’, three princes compete to win their father’s kingdom. The youngest, dismissed as a fool, follows his feather into the earth and discovers a remarkable subterranean world. His seemingly insignificant relationship with a toad ultimately wins him the kingdom. The story emphasises the capacity to descend beneath the dominant collective assumptions we have about competence and discover resources unavailable to conventional consciousness.

In ‘The Golden Goose’, the youngest of three sons, also called ‘Dummling’, shares his food with a little old man in the forest. In return, he receives a golden goose. Everyone who tries to take a feather becomes stuck to it, creating an extraordinary procession of people snared and transfixed by the narrow focus of their greed.. Kindness and generosity rather than self interested calculation generates the hero’s later abundance.

In ‘The Water of Life’, two older princes fail in their quest to find the healing water. The youngest succeeds because he listens to a dwarf whom his brothers have treated contemptuously, emphasising the ability to recognise and respect the seemingly insignificant. The ‘unsophisticated’ brother’s humility makes possible a relationship with the unknown.

What emerges from these stories is that attitude is everything. Dummling’s consideration of the ants, ducks and bees has significance far greater than the already considerable progression from having objects be present-to-hand, to the intersubjectivity of having the world be ready-at-hand where others are afforded the ontological validity of equal status.

Jung’s different types of thinking also have qualitatively distinct ways of relating to the Unconscious. Fantasy thinking affords inner objects, dream images and archetypal figures with subjective autonomy, embodying a symbolic attitude which experiences the psyche as being essentially alive and containing any number of independent loci of consciousness. Directive thinking tends to place itself at the centre of the psyche viewing other internal objects as derivative, as though what was in the unconscious was inert and there by virtue of repression rather than having an a priori existence from which consciousness itself is derived. Directed thinking views problem solving as something the ego does by itself by dint of strenuous effort. It is solipsistic and construes symbols and dreams as ‘parts-of-myself’ and thus subordinate to the ego, whereas fantasy thinking treats such phenomena as independent and charged with life in a way that will not permit the exploitation of the older brothers.

There are many everyday expressions which suggest we experience inner contents not simply as things we manufacture or possess, but as autonomous presences with something of their own life and agency. In common parlance we give testimony to this with such phrases as, ‘an idea came to me,’ rather than ‘I thought up an idea’. This is also expressed in the form, ‘Something is telling me…’ where an intuition is experienced as having its own voice. It’s stronger in the form of being ‘captured’ by an idea or intrusive thought.

‘It just occurred to me,’ denotes a thought arriving without conscious intention, as does, ‘I can’t get it out of my head,’ which acknowledges an image or thought as possessing a degree of autonomy. ‘The words wouldn’t come,’ here language is experienced as having its own availability or withdrawal. ‘Something took hold of me,’ describes an affect or complex experienced almost as an independent presence. ‘I need to sit with that,’ refers to the experience of an inner content requiring time and relationship rather than immediate action. ‘Getting out of one’s own way,’ suggests the recognition that conscious intention can impede solutions or suggestions from elsewhere in the psyche. ‘Something popped into my mind,’ expresses the autonomy of an idea. ‘I was triggered’, expresses the autonomy of an emotion. The concept of having a vocation, a calling, suggests intention outside ego’s perview, as does the experience of having a guiding star or a sense that things might be preordained, or conversely, ‘not meant to be’.

Such experiences of oneself do not require heroic action. They need sitting with and much staring out of the window. We might say that an inner image becomes ready-to-hand when we are in a living relationship with it. It is available to us, but not as an object under our control. We inhabit it, work with it, and allow it to disclose something. The Danish philosopher Kierkegaard gives expression to the reality of what we could call ‘autonomous complexes’ being sources of help and inspiration, ‘There is what I want to think about and there is what wants to be thought.’

The two ‘sophisticated’ brothers in our story suffer from what Jung calls, a ‘monotheism of consciousness’. (CW 13, §51) Jung writes, ‘Our true religion is a monotheism of consciousness, a possession by it, coupled with a fanatical denial that there are parts of the psyche which are autonomous.’ He observes that Western consciousness is characterised by the denial that these autonomous psychic systems can even be experienced. 

We have a tendency to assume that there is one centre of psychic authority, the ego, and that our thoughts, feelings and actions should be subject to conscious direction. What we cannot consciously understand or control is construed as either unreal, irrational or pathological. Autonomous psychic activity is something to be explained away rather than encountered. Jung calls this a monotheism because consciousness has effectively installed itself as the sole legitimate authority in psychic life.

In traditional cultures, autonomous psychic forces are frequently experienced as gods, spirits, demons, ancestors or other supernatural presences. Whatever their metaphysical status, these images give expression to the experience of psychic forces which are not under the control of conscious intention.

Modern scientific rationality has largely dispensed with these figures. But, Jung argues, it has not dispensed with the psychic forces themselves. They continue to manifest in dreams, fantasies, symptoms, compulsions, projections and autonomous complexes. The danger is that we have lost the symbolic language through which these forces might be recognised and related to. This danger is expressed somewhat poetically in a Russian variant of the Queen Bee story in which the Devil attempts to ‘educate’ the people by climbing up a high tower and haranguing them to use their heads, but he became so tired and dizzy that he lost his balance and fell to his death. The story ends, ‘isn’t that silly? Teaching the people to use their heads, the devil forgot all about his own body.’

Associative fantasy thinking with its musing, pottering circuity, offers a counterweight to the monotheism of consciousness, which if discouraged or devalued or ‘educated’ is bound to assume the symptomatic expression of neurotic inattention, just as any natural tendency will become troublesome and unruly if it’s invalidatated or disenfranchised.

Myths and fairy tales, the bulletin board of fantasy thinking, remind and reconnect us to a world in which the psyche has resources and intelligences besides conscious intention represented by animals which speak and possess wisdom, objects which have agency and power, situations in which the insignificant or foolish person may possess unexpected abilities, where unconscious figures intervene in human affairs and the protagonist may be required to submit to circumstances which cannot be mastered through intelligence or will.

In other words, they restore a sense of psychic balance through representing the plurality and autonomy of the psyche for what it actually is. It is for this reason that Einstein famously said, ‘do you want your children to be intelligent? Then read them fairy stories. If you want them to be more intelligent, read them more fairy stories.’ Steeping oneself in fantasy and imagination at an early age, finding value in the flowers by the wayside, allowing dolls, bears and imaginary figures to be suffused with life can often speak to life’s conundrums in a way that the later development of directed thinking cannot.

The Dummling in our story is an especially good example. His brothers operate through instrumental intelligence, calculation and conscious intention and are therefor powerless when faced with the king’s challenging tasks of finding the Princess’s pearls, her key, her identity. The Dummling is receptive to what appears insignificant, including the needs of animals. What his brothers dismiss as irrelevant becomes the source of his eventual transformation and good fortune.

The value of fantasy thinking can be taken a step further than the already advantageous sense that it provides both connectedness to inner and outer objects. Psychotherapy itself depends upon developing and strengthening this facility to bring about healing in the psyche. No emotional or psychological problem was ever remedied by a frontal assault, by intentional intervention. It is invariably a matter of free-association, musing, amplification, receptivity, paying attention to minutiae, and, like Parsifal, having the right question rather than clever answers.

If the therapist assumes that psychological development consists primarily in increasing the patient’s capacity for conscious understanding, adaptation and control, the therapeutic process risks reproducing precisely the monotheism Jung is criticising. Our task is rather to cultivate a relationship with autonomous psychic life.

This means allowing images, dreams, fantasies and symbolic narratives to retain something of their independence, rather than immediately translating them into rational explanations, Jung’s concept of the symbolic attitude, the capacity to experience an image or situation as something more than a sign whose meaning is already known. This requires the therapist to actively renounce ‘knowing’, to embrace mystery and the non-rational so that directive thinking then has some soil to grow in, so that conscious and unconscious can be co-operative rather than distractedly at each others throats.

Jung’s criticism of the monotheism of consciousness embodied in the exclusivity of directive thinking which then manifests symptomatically as ADHD, autism and other related difficulties, draws our attention to the danger of identifying psychic reality exclusively with the intentions and authority of the ego. Fairy tales and the revaluation of fantasy thinking preserve an alternative remedial vision; a plural, animate psychic world in which autonomous agencies possess their own significance and are essential participants in the process of transformation. We could go so far as to say that the primary purpose and true goal of therapy is not to resolve problems or to be free of neuroses but to re-member and develop fresh respect for the psychic ground out of which the ego itself emerged such that it may then bear creative fruit.

The Adventures of Baron von Trumphausen.

Baron Hieronymus Karl Friedrich Freiherr von Munchausen  (1720–1797) was a German nobleman whose adventurous life was later fictionalised in literature and film. Munchausen was a man whose extensive and vivid imagination surpassed even the grandeur of his title and many names. One of the most famous of Baron Munchausen’s exploits references an occasion he once found himself drowning in a swamp but managed to save himself by pulling himself out by his own hair. Of course he had many other tall tales, riding across a battlefield on a canon ball, flying to the moon, being swallowed by a giant fish but somehow its this capacity to rescue himself from the most dire of situations that captures the imagination, an image of heroic and magical self-sufficiency which will constitute the focus of our attention today.

It would be an unfortunate act of preemptive foreclosure to dismiss Munchausen as a mere liar. He was more of a master raconteur with a gift for poker faced embellishment, a kind of oral magician with a mesmeric capacity to beguile and blur the lines between fantasy and reality. His ‘lies’ were compelling confabulations which riveted his audiences, inspired imagination, enticed and enchanted. The great and the good fought for a seat at his myth-making dinner parties, competing for the privilege of being seduced into fantastical narrative told with performative exaggeration.

Munchausen’s ‘stories’ are important because they underscore how much we like to be deceived by the improbable and the impossible, why we ourselves are often moved to fib, prevaricate and dissemble, why it is that cheaters do in fact prosper. We may feel offended by the mendacious fudging of a barefaced lie, but our moral high ground runs the risk of getting in the way of exploring the purposes it might serve. Why it is that we collectively tolerate and even delight in pejorative cozenage? The story of Munchausen pulling himself from the swamp by his hair needs to be analysed both for its symbolic content and for its capacity to capture the imagination.

We normally associate lying with the attempt to avoid consequences and tend to regard the lie with opprobrium because it expresses the wish to simply get oneself out of trouble, or to remain at the centre of attention. Whilst Munchausen’s “lies” are exuberant, mythic fabrications expressing omnipotence and imaginative freedom, Munchausen Syndrome describes a psychiatric condition in which similar fabrications are focused on illness rather than adventure, a form of possession by the Trickster archetype, organised around a wounded child seeking care and recognition. In its most extreme form it involves deliberate falsification of symptoms and elaborate pathological storytelling motivated by the desire for attention, care, and psychological containment in order to avoid the rigours and demands of life.

Dig a little deeper and there is the lie which expresses the anxious need to stay congruent with a particular view of oneself, the lie which seeks to avoid not only consequence but also cognitive dissonance. Such a lie serves not only to avoid retribution but also to augment internal cohesion, congruence designed to avoid getting into trouble with yourself by minimising internal conflict or contradiction. This shifts the focus from the lies we tell others to those we tell ourselves.

Then there’s a deeper level still, a descent from naughty to nasty, in which the lie is designed not just to avoid censure or to help you feel better about yourself but when it is yoked to the kind of desire for power over others which tolerates and even requires collateral damage and the suffering of third parties. Such lies are meant to fuck with your head and destroy relatedness, the kind of lie designed not to get yourself out of shit but to put others in it. At this juncture the lie is synonymous with sadistic cruelty. Its purpose is deeper than intra-psychic consistency and becomes more a question of preserving a sense of self via the persecution of others. The shift here is Copernican because the lie is being actively employed to depersonalise and project inferiority. Its maintenance requires jackboots and active victimisation.

The most pernicious lie however, encapsulating all of the above but not limited to them, is the one symbolised by Munchausen pulling himself out of the swamp by his hair. I am sufficient to myself. I don’t need you. The other is not simply victimised but eradicated.

Whilst Munchausen syndrome is a pathological possession by the Trickster archetype, in which the ego constructs grandiose illness narratives to secure maternal containment and narcissistic mirroring while defending against fragmentation and dependency, the story of him pulling himself out of the swamp by his hair serves the same purpose, but by identifying with the opposite, absolute invulnerability. Trickster is now augmented with Magician.

Danish philosopher Soren Kierkegaard refers to such a condition as a ‘sickness unto death.’ Kierkegaard defines the self as essentially relational. It relates to itself and is grounded in a power beyond itself. When this relation is misaligned despair threatens, requiring further efforts to secure oneself by even greater efforts to be one’s own ground. The individual refuses to experience themselves as dependent. Instead, they attempt to author and sustain an identity by sheer will and imagination. The Baron pulling himself out of a swamp by his own hair is the symbolic representation of Kierkegaard’s defiant self. This is not healthy autonomy, no self can provide its own ultimate foundation. The attempt to do so leads to increasingly elaborate performances of self-sufficiency, ultimately a magnificent but impossible effort to become one’s own creator.

Where Søren Kierkegaard diagnoses the spiritual structure of defiant selfhood, and Carl Jung interprets the archetypal symbolism, Swiss psychiatrist and philosopher Karl Jaspers asks a distinct question, what kind of human possibility is disclosed when a person lives within stories that are factually impossible yet existentially meaningful? What does the fabricated narrative accomplish for that person?

A return to Kierkegaard provides the answer, behind defiant self-assertion often lies the opposite despair, an inability to tolerate one’s ordinary, vulnerable identity. The grandiose storyteller implicitly says, ‘The self I have been given is intolerable, therefore I will invent another.’ The impossible adventure covers a more painful reality of utter dependency and disastrous insufficiency.

According to The Washington Post Fact Checker, President Trump told 30,573 false or misleading claims during his first presidency. They all fall, with chillingly precision, into the different categories detailed above. From the attempts to garner sympathy and avoid consequence with his factitious bone spurs, to the lies he tells himself about crowd sizes and how popular he is, to the lies about migrants involving the justification of putting children in cages, to the lies about being exonerated from responsibility for having appeared on every other page of the Epstein files, to the bombing of Iran based on the lie that they are developing a nuclear weapon. But the scariest lie by far is the image posted on Truth Social of him as Jesus. In that image, Trickster and Magician are now bolstered by Saviour, come together to form a truly unholy trinity.

Perhaps the only thing that should concern us more is that Trump is not the problem. He is a symptom of the problem. The anti-christ is neither the devilish opposite of Jesus nor even the poor fool with nuclear codes who mistakes himself for Jesus, but the pervasive collective sentiment which no longer cares whether the most powerful man in the world lies, rapes, steals, cheats and kills… or not.

The Sado-Masochistic Self.

Sado-Masochism has much in common with the elusive, lesser spotted Venus Fly Trap Warbler. They both have fancy names and are so well camouflaged that even the ardent enthusiast rarely gets a peek. Danish philosopher and leading contender for the Worst-luck-in-love Competition, Soren Kierkegaard, who also had a fancy name, tells the following cautionary tale ….

There was once a poor peasant who was so down on his luck he did not even have a pair of shoes to wear.

One day, he miraculously came into some money.  He walked all the way into town and bought the finest pair of shoes he could find. There was even some money left over. So he bought a jug of wine and drank it on the way home.

Before he could return, the wine got the better of him. He fell into a ditch where he passed out. In the small hours of the morning a coach came by. The coachman sees the peasant’s legs dangling out of the ditch across the road and he calls out loudly lest they be run over. The peasant raises a bleary eye, looks carefully at his newly shod feet and shouts back, ‘they’re not my legs, drive on!’

Since S/M is about what happens between people it would be better to say that it is a perversion of the Principle of Relatedness, of which sexual relatedness is only a part. The flamboyant/erotic end of the spectrum may well catch our attention but many S/M enactments are  of the common or garden varieties and don’t make for interesting TV.

Nor is it enough to then say that S/M is rooted in dominance and subordination. These are expressions of and adaptations to something more fundamental which is still worth naming.

The child of any epoch or culture instinctively maintains the conditions in which it has learned to be at home. If disconnection and split realities are the world we are born into then even these…

”will be maintained indiscriminately as part of development.” Jean Liedloff

This relational dysfunction is much bigger than the sexual issues they might later encompass.

Narcissistic sadism has, as its prime objective, the eradication of the other’s subjective reality. Its means to that end is depersonalization, humiliation, witholding and the refusal to value or accommodate. His doing-unto-others denies and projects a fragile core. I wound therefore I am…

not my wound.

Empathic masochism dovetails this with low self worth, poor boundaries and subliminal victim mentality that colludes with and allows the sadist’s  ‘bad behavior’. Power and responsibility are abdicated so Identity can take root in being done to.

”They are not my legs, ride on!”

The problem for the poor peasant is that if his poverty constitutes a nucleus of identity, a core self-construct, then the resolution of it will precipitate existential crisis. He won’t know who he is anymore. Resolving ‘the problem’, is therefor out of the frying pan…

and into the fire.

”Once you have identified with some form of negativity you do not want to let it go and on a deeply unconscious level, do not want positive change. It would threaten your identity as a depressed, angry or hard done-by person. Eckhart Tolle.

So we resist what we want most because it costs us what we know of ourselves to have it.

”For someone who’s natural habitat is the brink of disaster, a giant step into security is as intolerable as the realization of all he fears most.” Jean Liedloff.

Our peasant’s new shoes threaten his whole view of life. He cannot afford to identify with his own good fortune. Having his legs run over would reacquaint him with his familiar bad luck upon which identity has long been constructed.

Moreover, the miracle of his wild adventure into town has the quality of a hero’s quest, part of which is invariably death/rebirth. If this is not realized in the inner world it will be enacted in the outer.

”Creativity… expresses itself in the ambivalent experience of rebirth through death (or) in sado-masochistic fantasies.” Erich Neumann.

The process of self-realization involves some painful  processes over and above the unearthing of childhood trauma because it involves an end to the notion that we are masters of our own houses. This tends to lead either to a positive inflation in which ego identifies with the Self and becomes cruel, inconsiderate and puffed up with power, or a negative inflation in which we feel lower than a worm and deserving of nothing.

Its easier to act this out in our relationships than it is to contain the violent forces that can swing us back and forth between such extremes.

The alchemical tradition, which offers us a metaphor  for the process of individuation, is full of grisly symbolism. The ‘mortificatio’ and ‘putrefacto’ are stages of the journey in which the old sense of identity dies and rots as a result of the encounter with the Self. These ‘torments’ are described as…

”cutting up the limbs, dividing them into smaller and smaller pieces and mortifying the parts.” Rosarium.

This painful process is amplified in Solomon’s ‘Song of Songs’, in which the difficult encounter between bride and bridegroom represent the clash of opposites often described between ego and Self.

”The coniunctio is both desired and dreaded. From a distance it is the source of all yearning, but knocking at our door it is an object of terror.” E. Edinger.

In Solomon’s Song the bridegroom is wounded..

”You ravish my heart with a single one of your glances…”

This acknowledgement between self and ego….

”has a wounding or violating effect.” Edinger.

In Christian iconography this is represented by Jesus on the cross.

‘thou didst wound my heart with one of thine eyes when, hanging upon the cross, I was wounded for love of thee that I might make thee my bride.” ibid

In the Bahavad Gita, Arjuna asks to see Krishna’s true form and quickly regrets it.

”when I see you touching the sky, blazing with many colours, with mouths open wide, with large fiery eyes, my heart trembles in fear and I find neither courage nor peace. Devouring all the worlds on every side, you lick your lips. I implore you, as a lover to the beloved, show me a gentler form.”

The wish for mother confounded by the need to separate from her and the feeling of being  torn apart that this can constitute in early life, is a motif that can attend spiritual awakening in later years. They share the common experience of an encounter with Other.

A favorite delusion is that one’s own destiny is simply something to yearn for. But somehow circumstances entangle from the true path… from where you are supposed to be.. forgetting that the path we seek is the one we are on and for good reason. The creatures that used to hide in the closet and under the bed along with all those that come in through the cracks from Elsewhere along the way, have taken up lodging in your outer world and become life’s spiky situations instead.

The boy who wanted to know Fear.

Some post-doctoral research has recently been done titled, ‘Reconditioning the brain to Overcome Fear.   ”http://scitechconnect.elsevier.com/reconditioning-the-brain-to-overcome-fear/

How scary is that? I don’t fancy being reconditioned. I like me the way I am, warts and all , some of which has been shot at, stabbed and incarcerated. What I really hate is folk trying to get into my soft mushy parts with the AI equivalent of a monkey wrench.

We seem to have forgotten what fear is for.

A story that exemplifies this is, ‘The boy who wanted to know Fear’, or, ‘The boy who wanted to Shudder”.

A man had two sons. The eldest was smart. The youngest was supposedly stupid and made to feel the more so when he expressed as his deepest wish to learn how to shudder. His father and elder brother mock him and turn him out to seek his ‘foolish’ quest.

He spends a night beneath hanged men whom he tries to warm by his fire. He kicks the local sexton down the stairs who’d dressed up as a ghost in the attempt to frighten him. He plays with and kills ghostly cats and dogs that attack him. He plays skittles with skulls and ninepin bones. Corpses revive and try to choke him… Nothing works.

Finally he marries the king’s daughter because of all this ‘courage’. She, on the advice of her chambermaid, fetches a cold bucket of water from the stream full of tiny wriggling minnows and soaks him while he sleeps. At last he learns how to shudder.

The story suggests that there is something about fear that is necessary to human development, that to know fear is a kind of quest.

”Whoever has learned to be anxious in the right way has learned the ultimate.” Kierkegaard.

The obvious bit is that fear warns us of danger. It flags up our fight or flight response. It reprioritises. And if its spiders that scare its  because we’ve already ‘reconditioned’ ourselves not to be afraid of some legitimate childhood horror and  have had to crush authentic being for the sake of going-on-being, an effective strategy that manages to project and concretise undigestible experience.

Our story says that there is something essential about fear, and not just of circumstantial things, but also of objectless…

”…anxiety from below, calling out to each one of us concerning our very being. Learning to be anxious in the right way will involve coming into dialogue with this messenger.” A.S. Soderquist.

The process of growing up means an encounter with the Other, with Not-me. Both the Not-Me out there in the world and the Not-Me in ‘here’, that wells up from beneath, that informs while we sleep, that leaves its trail all through your backyard.

”He who seeks, let him not cease seeking until he finds; and when he finds he will be troubled.” Gnostic gospel of Thomas.

The plague of psychological enquiry is its insistence on trying to understand. Jung himself confessed to..

”..wanting to understand above all else.”

which, given the vastness of the Unconscious, is a bit like being captured by a fascination for cream crackers at a gourmet dinner. All in lieu of the spine tingling realisation that what you are looking for is also looking for you… and won’t be understood precisely because it transcends comprehension.

”It is the duty of the human understanding to understand that there are things which it cannot understand.” S. Kirkeggard.

Which is why characters from the bible are always in mighty dread of one form or another and Arjuna from the Bhagavad Gita begs Vishnu to hide his true face.

”When I see you touching the sky, blazing with many colours, with large fiery eyes, my heart trembles in fear and I can find neither courage nor peace. Be gracious, O Abode of the Universe.”

In the Grail legend we find Lancelot attracted to a room in the castle from which emanates a bright glow. He sees the holy vessel on a silver table, approaches too close and is scalded by a hot wind that stikes him deaf, blind and paralysed for twenty four hours.

So there is something intrinsically scary, something awe-ful, about encounter with Not-Me, and not simply because its bigger than us but because we are changed in the process.

”The hallmark of the transpersonal is that it acts upon us.” S. B-Perrera.

Our hero is not initiated into trepidation by his father, who both fails and rejects him. The contempt of this father is thinly based hostility at the boy wanting his own destiny. Its also the inheritance of a social model based on kingship where father/son relations are mared by power struggles you don’t find in societies that have chiefs.

In modern times we may not resort to the excesses of Edward the third who stuck a red hot poker up his dad’s bum, or even an Abraham willing to slit his son’s throat cos god told him to, but we have ‘lost’ the initiation of sons by their fathers which might better manage life’s fears and prevent us from approaching fear as if it were synonymous with illness.

I went to see my analyst once, shoulders hunched and all sorry for myself, ”I feel so disillusioned, ” I proclaimed. He hesitated a bit and then said, ‘..but that’s a good thing.”

Learning the meaning of fear is essential to resolving any narcissistic adaptation. Fortunately for our hero he realises this and goes looking in the world for what his father cannot provide.

The DSM specifically mentions this curious absence of fear in the Narcissistic personality. The reason is that the Narcissist hasn’t yet had the initiatory encounter with Otherness. Everything is an extension of his world. So there is no loss, abandonent or death. He has yet to experience what Fordham calls ‘de-integration’, the structural unbundling of the Self that is encounter with any altering Other. Jung was fond of saying that good therapy is when the analyst is changed as well….

Our hero does not learn how to shudder from his own efforts. He’s even asleep at the time. But his longing to discover the secret brings him into relatedness with his wife and the ‘Nursemaid’ who sees what is needed and kindly rains on his parade. This sudden awakening is rude and unexpected. It can’t be otherwise since what’s at stake is a paradigm shift in consciousness from self-as-centre to being one-amongst-many, the psychological equivalent of Galileo’s shock that the earth revolves around the sun and not the other way around.

Such realisations are bound to be resisted even while we do our best to enquire into them because of the ground breaking consequences to our perception of reality that is involved. So if you feel stuck you might cut yourself a little slack. Growing is a scary business.

And anyway what could two PhD’s in Engineering and Telecommunications do with research that suppressed fear? I mean, other than weaponise it….

How scary…